Sad: Ross Douthat and Ben Domenech Urge President Trump To Be More Populist

Do you know how bad President Trump’s drift away from populism has gotten? It is so bad that even Ross Douthat and Ben Domenech are calling him out on it:


“Where policy was concerned, the story of Donald Trump’s first year in office was simple: The populist of the campaign trail, the man who won the Republican nomination and the White House by ignoring conservative orthodoxy and promising the moon, was replaced by a president who essentially conceded control of his agenda to Paul Ryan and Mitch McConnell and spent down his limited political capital pursuing conventionally right-wing policies — unsuccessfully on health care, successfully on taxes, but in each case without much moderate or bipartisan support. …

So this State of the Union both showed what a more successful version of the Trump presidency would look like — still conservative on many fronts but more genuinely populist, less same-old G.O.P. — and why the possibility of that success has probably already slipped from this administration’s grip. There were ideas here that could make Trump’s second year more successful than the first, but there was no plan to actually enact them, no sign that Trump is prepared to build bridges where he’s burned them, no plan for getting more out of this speech than just a temporary polling bump. …”


“During the campaign, it became clear that a major part of Mr. Trump’s appeal was that he frequently broke with Republican orthodoxies on a host of issues, including foreign policy, trade, entitlements, health care and, to some degree, immigration. His unorthodoxy proved to be an asset for his campaign and is among the reasons exit polls indicated he prevailed over Hillary Clinton among independent voters.

Yet these same independents are by and large the supporters Mr. Trump has lost over the past year. Much of this is no doubt due to the tenor of this presidency and the daily barrage of tweets, leaks, investigations and general partisanship that is the hallmark of Washington these days. But his loss of support among independents may also be partly because his presidency has turned out to be much more generically Republican than what many anticipated. …

As Republicans work to make traditional conservatism and populist Trumpism coexist harmoniously inside their party, creativity is required to achieve compromises on policy goals. By making paid family leave a signature issue for 2018, President Trump would be embracing an idea at the heart of his 2016 success: that he is the one Republican willing to break with party norms to help working- and middle-class Americans.”

Yes, the conservative braintrust who feared Trump’s hostile takeover of the GOP during the campaign would destroy conservatism are now worried that he didn’t mean any of his populist campaign rhetoric and that voters now perceive him as too conservative.

Note: President Trump’s political brand has done a 180 degree turn over the last year. Whereas he was once perceived as the most moderate Republican president in over twenty years, he is now perceived as the most conservative president since Ronald Reagan.

About Hunter Wallace 12368 Articles
Founder and Editor-in-Chief of Occidental Dissent


  1. Doggone it, I’m going to say this again: Trump does not represent a return to American greatness, he is not going to restore/reform/renew/rebuild anything. He represents the last gasp of an old, discredited system that should’ve been done away with 150 years ago. I think he will be nothing more than a transitional figure like Mikhail Gorbachev.

    Who or what comes after Trump is unknown. Maybe his son Barron will seize power in a coup and become a new Bonoparte or Caesar. Maybe the USA will break up into smaller republics. Maybe we’ll be plunged into a 100 year long civil war. But there’s no going back to business as usual under another GW Faggot, Bathhouse Barry or Slick Willie.

  2. All it takes is an R after the name, a bunch of rightoid bluster, screams of horror from the media and bingo, the sheeple think your George Washington revived (Hitler to liberals).

    Similarly, most pew-warmers think their preacher is a great fire-breathing conservative moralist etc if he just raises his voice sometimes or hammers hammers hammers on salvation and your urgent need for it as an abstraction cut off from the rest of life and artificially made the entirety of existence.

    Style is everything to sheeple, substance nil.

    • Can your bigotry. I could cite some home truths about how your lot are easily lead and plowing the furrows of emptiness. I started reading this site a few months ago, and while I found value in some articles, mostly I could t help but wonder if you all aren’t being played.. something just doesn’t make sense when you apply some clear linear thought. For a group that claims an objective goal, you appear to be the equivalent of BSers jerking around, who while occasionally seeming to express insight, always I dunno a lot reads like a group of fanboys/girls of something lameass like Ghosthunters or the Cthulhu Mythos

  3. Douthat and Domenich are basically trolling Trump supporters to seed divides. The fact is Trump either lied, or he is being played, by media poking him where it hurts, his ego. Plus his tramp daughter either plays the guilt card to steer him leftward.

Comments are closed.