Robert Lindsay on Disingenuous White Liberals

Being a Disingenuous White Liberal is about not being a Southerner

California

In his recent interview with Voice of Reason, Robert Lindsay has some fascinating comments about the mindset of Disingenuous White Liberals.

DWLs are not stupid or misinformed. They know that race exists. They know that racial differences are intractable because even they believe that heredity is the likely culprit. This is why these people are seemingly so impervious to rational arguments.

How do we explain the insanity of anti-racism then?

As Lindsay explains to Stark, it has a lot to do with the need to not be perceived as a Southerner, especially a low class White Southerner like a Scots-Irish redneck or a hillbilly who is prejudiced against blacks.  Those people are “backward” and “ignorant.” They are not good liberals and enlightened progressives like us.

See, it is part of their ethnic identity: for many of these “Disingenuous White Liberals,” the essence of being a Yankee is not being a Southerner, which means not being a racist or a religious conservative. The White Southerner is “the Other.” We are their out-group. We are they to them.

Admitting that the South is right about the Black Undertow is not an argument that can be rationally weighed on its own merits. On the contrary, it is an existential challenge to the very core being of Yankeedom.

If the Southern redneck is smarter than the Harvard professor, what does that say about Yankee culture? If the South was right about African-Americans, what does that say about the last 150 years of American history? What does that say about the War Between the States and Reconstruction and the Civil Rights Movement?

How else can we explain the existence of Detroit and Philadelphia? The Whites who live in Michigan and Pennsylvania must be suffering from some kind of mass delusion  – a delusional and idolatrous belief in equality – to tolerate the destruction of their own civilization by African barbarism.

About Hunter Wallace 12392 Articles
Founder and Editor-in-Chief of Occidental Dissent

50 Comments

  1. The whites who live in Pennsylvania and Michigan do not by and large live in the ghettoes of Philadelphia and Detroit. Michigan and Pennsylvania can easily be described as swing states with a lot of blue collar Reagan Democrats and are definitely more conservative than California, New York, and New England. I think Obama is in serious trouble when it comes to re-election in 2012.

    My question is how can whites live completely surrounded by masses of niggers wherever they turn in the humid, fetid, and pestilential climate of the South? It’s just not a right way for a white man to live.

  2. (1) I would rather live around masses of niggers than among liberal Yankees and the suffocating conformism of their insane anti-racist culture. Southerners imagine the North as being a place where Whites actually believe in political correctness and liberalism.

    (2) I suppose we are accustomed to the weather. The only bad time of the year in the South is the summer which has been mitigated by air conditioning.

    (3) How can anyone live in the North with its bleak and cold climate? I can’t imagine what it must be like to have to dig yourself out of the snow. It rarely snows in Alabama. We have great fall and spring weather and mild winters.

  3. >>(1) I would rather live around masses of niggers than among liberal Yankees and the suffocating conformism of their insane anti-racist culture. <>(2) I suppose we are accustomed to the weather. The only bad time of the year in the South is the summer which has been mitigated by air conditioning. <<

    Truthfully most of the US has a bad climate. The South is too hot in the summer and too cold in the winter. I haven't lived in the Northeast or Midwest, but it's only a matter of the portion of too hot/too cold. Only coastal California has good year-round weather; south Florida is great eight months of the year, bearable the other four.

    Non- or anti-racism is at least as much a status marker separating upper middle-class whites from working-class whites in the Northeast and Midwest, but Lindsay wouldn't be familiar with that, apparently living in California his whole life.

  4. @Rudel

    I can’t think of a major Northern city, and its suburbs that isn’t full of Blacks, Puerto Ricans, Mexicans, Latinos, Asians, Jews & other Orientals of all discriptions.

  5. DWLs made Jared Diamond a rich man, but its rare to find a DWL who actually believes the Blank Slate Theory. If you can figure out that riddle let me know.

    If you ever get a chance to actually question a DWL, its a mind blowing experience, so much cognitive dissonance there it is not even quantifiable.

  6. @Rudel

    Btw, you have a silly “Gone With The Wind” view of farming in the antebellum South. If you think the Southern farmer could afford to hire layers of outside management to supervise his slaves you have been reading too much fiction—Simon Legree was a fictional character!

  7. Detroit has sweltering, Africa-like summers, and Arctic winters with snowfall that averages in the double-digits. The worst of both worlds. And of course, it goes without saying, that there is a nigger problem here. My observation is that the white people here are in a weird condition.. They rightly despise blacks, and the resentment and rage towered them is palpable, but whites here just bottle it up. It’s like they’re just too numb anymore.. I dunno, oppressed peoples have collectively snapped before, as history illustrates, but my fellow Foundry-mutts seem like they’ve resigned themselves to oblivion. Maybe it’s because of our ethnic admixture — we were bred from everyone, so in essence, we’re no one. Maybe people like myself represent the beginning stage of “The Global Plantation” that WN crowd talks about — disparate European peoples interbreeding and birthing a new race, “the American”, and the long-term goal being the forced interbreeding of the rest of the planet–endgame example: Obama. Maybe because of that, we lost some important survival gene in becoming “American”. I hope not, but sometimes I have to wonder.

    Northern and rural Michigan isn’t as catatonic, but folks out there are very indifferent to anything that goes on outside of sphere of their families and local communities. So I don’t how it’s going to play out. For certain, the present order is unnatural and inherently unsustainable, but the necessary will to bring it down, just feels missing.

    As far as 2012 goes, I could see Michigan going for Romney in such a match-up, but anyone else, it ends up in Obama’s column.

  8. Of course the Jews are very supportive of the present system. The polls show that African-Americans are the most supportive. We kind of take that for granted around here.

    The real mystery is why Whites are supportive of the present system. In some areas, there is a sense of resignation to the status quo. In other areas, Whites seem to really believe in the system and even look forward to pushing it forward to new extremes.

    In California, over 50 percent of Whites voted for Obama in 2008. The state has become a bankrupt and declining Third World cesspool, but the Whites who remain there (many others have voted with their feet) put Jerry Brown in power who recently signed the California DREAM Act. Especially when the specters of Detroit and Los Angeles are in their midst.

    In states like Alabama and Mississippi, 10 to 12 percent of the White population voted for Obama. We don’t understand why states like Michigan and California simply can’t stop themselves from voting for militantly anti-racist Democrats.

    It is hard to say that Whites are victims when the White majority in many of the Blue States votes for the likes of Barack Hussein Obama and Eric “My People” Holder.

  9. “I can’t think of a major Northern city, and its suburbs that isn’t full of Blacks, Puerto Ricans, Mexicans, Latinos, Asians, Jews & other Orientals of all discriptions.”

    Bullshit. The suburbs of Pacific Northwest and Mountain West cities are devoid of Negroes and spics. There are more and more beaners in rural areas but we are certainly still far whiter than the Eastern cities and the South.

    Just look at the county by county 20101 US Census maps.

  10. “Btw, you have a silly “Gone With The Wind” view of farming in the antebellum South. If you think the Southern farmer could afford to hire layers of outside management to supervise his slaves you have been reading too much fiction—Simon Legree was a fictional character”

    Your “honor hard work” blue collar roots are showing. Aristocracies don’t “work”, they rule. Who do you think the 1% everybody has been complaining about are?

  11. “DWLs made Jared Diamond a rich man, but its rare to find a DWL who actually believes the Blank Slate Theory.”

    Jared Diamond didn’t write the Blank Slate, Steven Pinker did. Diamond’s “Guns, Germs, and Steel” argue opposite points. Which Jew do you agree with BTW?

  12. “Only coastal California has good year-round weather; south Florida is great eight months of the year, bearable the other four.

    Maybe to a wop or greek like yourself. Hardly to a white European who finds snow and winter sports invigorating.

  13. The South has sick White Liberals just like the North. The rich send their kids to private schools and live in a fantasy world, not the real world. The future must a have a Shipping Program. Old White Jim is right! The worse problems is the controlling Khazars and Mixed Royalty, they have only one FATE that awaits them! Monsanto is getting rid of all of us with their GMO Foods. GMO Foods cause sterility in three generations and destroys Liver and Kidney functions. Plus the Flouride drinking water, processed Salt and White Flour combo creates ZOMBIES, who dont think or question and the cell phones burns the brains up. Ever notice how the heavy cell phone user ever once and awhile gets this crazy blank stare void look and gaze? The Powers That Be want to depopulate earth to 500,000,000. Do you think Khazars and Royalty have an anedote so GMO Foods dont get them to? If so, what is it, they just dont eat GMO Foods or what? Get out of Babylon or die! Wake up White Man!

  14. ” I suppose we are accustomed to the weather. The only bad time of the year in the South is the summer which has been mitigated by air conditioning.”

    I like opening the windows and feeling the summer breeze. Had tour genes analyzed yet. Perhaps your acclimatization is due to an unacknowledged nigger in the ancestral woodpile.

  15. The Southern & Appalachian Ulster-Scots are the “BAD” whites. All the others are “good whites.” Especially “conservatives.” They are more DWL than the DWLs. Military live on public paychecks, just like people on Welfare, but they they are socially “necessary,” and “helpers” who save the world— the ultimate in a yankee– imposing their grand Idea on others (while going on about “self-determination” and “freedom of conscience.”)

    Deep down, DWLs know Southern-Appalachian are the “other,” the mirror image. So they will only hate them more and more. The silence of “the other” carries the potential to point out that the “good whites” aren’t nearly as good as their self-generated accounts claim they are. The Southern-Appalachian is the other side of history, the unspoken.

    So the greatest threat is that a Southern, an Appalachian, a WASP, a person from “flyover” country—those folks– will actually just say something.

  16. Whites are supportive of the present system because if you step outside the boundaries of acceptable discourse you are drummed out of polite company and can lose your job.

    Look at academia. The strictest arena of discourse in the country.

    Abandon all freedom of inquiry ye who enter here.

  17. @ John Thomas “The South has sick White Liberals just like the North…”

    Sort of. In reality— the real point is that the “liberals” of the North and South are motivated in completely different ways.

    A Northeast “liberal” is a whole different animal from the Southern-Appalachian liberal. And the Northeast person —who has not lived a life from the social position of the “other,” as the Repository of American Badness— is a ‘liberal’ for very different reasons. The Northeasterner can NEVER really anticipate the motivational psychological structure of the southerner or appalachian.

    As people who ‘own’ the public narrative, own the t.v. voice, etc, they have never really thought about how their attitudes have affected people in the rest of the country. They are —sadly for them— positioned to “believe their own press.”

    The voice of the “other,” the southerner, the appalachian, the flyover countries, are just Lies, from their point of view. They are “them” as HW says.

  18. ” Maybe it’s because of our ethnic admixture — we were bred from everyone, so in essence, we’re no one. “

    You are not bred from “no one.” You are bred from the Indo-Aryan horseman and cattle herders (it’s why you can drink and metabolize milk) from the Eurasian steps who migrated to and populated Europe 3000 years ago and gave rise to the Celts, Germans, and Latins. That’s why most Western Europeans belong to the Y-chomosome haplogroup R1B1B2A1 and speak linguistingly similar languages.

    Ever see a Roman bust? They look like white men because they are white men. Modern Italians not so much.

  19. I post under my real name in the local paper and I’m known as an “anti-semite,” whatever the hell that means. So my neighbor invites me and the wife over for dinner. Obviously he has read some of my posts. So he makes a big deal about how when he was young he would get a ride home from school from his friend’s Dad and the guy would go on rants about the Jews. So he told his own Dad, and his Dad said, “son, you’re not riding with them anymore.” So he says he can’t stand anti-semitism, because his Daddy didn’t like it.

    Well, I says, your Daddy didn’t like it because if the business community found out his son had been riding in the car with a known Jew basher, your Daddy would have been drummed out of polite company. So your Daddy was a goddam coward, and so are you. You don’t tell me about culture and I won’t tell you about your business.

    Actually, I didn’t say that. Shit, he was having us over for dinner. But WTF??? This country, outside of private little chats like this here blog, is a wholly owned subsidiary of Jew, Inc.. The blacks don’t mean shit, except as a convenient club the Jews can use to beat Whitey into submission. Let’s face it, if Whites do ANYTHING, world Jewry will DESTROY this country, just like Germany.

    Is it disingenuous to want to put food on the table?

  20. Spooky,

    It is disturbing that your neighbor feels compelled to invite you over for dinner to mind your business. As much as we argue sometimes here among ourselves, we don’t ever really get morally self righteous, even when discussing polarizing topics like Reconstruction.

    Everyone here is entitled to their own point of view. We enjoy the lively discussions. There isn’t a suffocating atmosphere of conformism. Everything is argued and debated and we all learn from each other in the process.

  21. @ Rudel

    Bullshit, huh?

    Seattle, Washington is over 30% non-White even by today’s lax standards.

  22. Rudel all jews believe in the blank slate theory of enviroment over genes, including the two worthies you mention. They go nuts to hear otherwise.

  23. Natural Law will ALWAYs prevail. If a retardate mental case like Lindsay sez that the DWL loonies do what they do, smply because they don’t want to be considered a “southern Redneck ” – then they have essentially ADMITTED THAT SOUTHERN REDNECKS WERE RIGHT ALL ALONG.

    He’s admttted it.

    It’s 2 seconds fron all falling apart. This is the best harbinger of the collapse of the BRA, than anything.

  24. “It’s 2 seconds fron all falling apart. This is the best harbinger of the collapse of the BRA, than anything.”

    I agree. It just has to be. But then, I thought the same thing in 1965.

  25. “The object in life is not to be on the side of the majority, but to escape finding oneself in the ranks of the insane.”

    It’s a fine line.

  26. Bill – get over yourself. It’s 40 years on. Whitey’s been through a lot of changes. The USA was what – 90% White, in 1965?

  27. “Bill – get over yourself. It’s 40 years on. Whitey’s been through a lot of changes. The USA was what – 90% White, in 1965?”

    I can appreciate that. What I’m asking YOU is why some kind of revolt is more likely now that Whites near minority status as when they were comfortably in the majority. Because they were comfortable? No, it isn’t so. It’s only because they swallowed the Uncle Sam bullshit. It is that stupid and unwarranted, but Wall St.-induced devotion that prevented a military revolt in 1965. That may be water over the bridge but it was a lot closer than the forms of rebellion I see today.

  28. Looking at the exit polls for California, Illinois, Michigan, Pennsylvania and even Maine, it is, with the exception of a small majority in Pennsylvania, white Catholic majorities that voted for Obama. Essentially, the descendants of southern and eastern Europeans and Irish Catholics still stand against the WASP founding American. The exception is a state like Louisiana whose Catholic population is large and influential but of different ethnic origin.

  29. interesting point DJ and I’d like to see the polling. Have a link? If true, the lesson to be learned is, Whites of another tribe are not automatically on the same side as my tribe. Which is something I’ve always known at the gut level but it’s interesting to see that gut instinct backed up

  30. RobRoySimmons wites:

    “Rudel all jews believe in the blank slate theory of enviroment over genes, including the two worthies you mention. They go nuts to hear otherwise.”

    The Blank Slate actually comes down on the side of genes over environment (it being a refutation of the blank slate) which you would know if you actually read the book you dumb fuck poser.

  31. “Whites of another tribe are not automatically on the same side as my tribe.”

    That , I think, is the main reason in a nut shell why there has been no “rebellion” from 1965 to present. The White race as a racial monolith has never existed. Our bloodiest and most catastrophic wars have been among ourselves.

    The Irish are a funny bunch. How do you get a Joe McCarthy and a Ted Kennedy; a Father Coughlin and the Beringan brothers? I’m sure it’s no accident that they were/are as unwelcomed as darkies in certain quarters.

    Perhaps Hunter will do an article about it sometime?

  32. “See, it is part of their ethnic identity: for many of these “Disingenuous White Liberals,” the essence of being a Yankee is not being a Southerner, which means not being a racist or a religious conservative. The White Southerner is “the Other.” We are their out-group. We are they to them.”

    HUNTER- THAT’S IT!!!!!!

    No WONDER I can’t get through to my ‘friends’ and ‘colleagues’ – they’re all Yankee Supremacists!

    God bless you. Truly.

  33. “(3) How can anyone live in the North with its bleak and cold climate? I can’t imagine what it must be like to have to dig yourself out of the snow. It rarely snows in Alabama. We have great fall and spring weather and mild winters.”

    Snow and winter help us Northerners (especially Pious Scandics) to know our own mortality. A way to look at it is to read a couple of books: for children Lois Lenski’s “Dakota Girl” and for adults “No place to go but stay.” (don’t remember the author)

    Winter with snow enables you to RELISH (absolutely relish) twentieth-century inventions like the furnace, insulation, and thermopane windows. It also could NEVER be Christmas without at least a foot of snow. I know- I tried denying that part of my genetic memory by living in So Cal. Every December, I got depressed, BECAUSE it wasn’t ‘right’ NOT to have snow. I’m much better now. And snow blowers make ‘shoveling’ something even an old fogey can do, and feel like he’s REALLY accomplished something. Besides, it also halts the consumerist drone culture after a snow storm… and keeps the Somali Bastards off the streets for a few days. And, of course, it makes the whole world WHITE… for a while! Cheers.

  34. Blacks are not the problem, capitalists are. If Whites and Blacks view each other as the main problem, big business owners benefit. How do you go on strike or demonstrate if black workers and white workers are more focused on their race than on building mass power to uplift the working class.

    In fact, some of the things considered negative about blacks are actually a good thing. Violent, rebellious, doesn’t follow orders. Well that’s exactly what we need to take out the bourgeoisie.

  35. Metal Gear – Iceman: Blacks are a problem. Drive a car at night thru their Ghetto hoods and see what happens to you when you stop at a red light. You better have some lead to throw. They will surround your car, kill you maybe and hi jack your car. This is true for all large metro cities in the USA. George Lincoln Rockwell tried to work with Black Muslims. Also Terrible Tommy (Tom Metzger) has spoke to Black Muslim Groups Meetings. The Black Muslins hate us, but they dont mix and want their own country. Some Blacks, not all will help you when you are in ditch and need to be pulled out. The Khazar Zionist and the White Liberals that Hunter talks about will not help you out of the ditch, a small amount, very small might help you. But in most cases they will not. Whoever helps us is Blessed, Whoever Curses us is Cursed! I read on Rense.com a Henry Makow article about Luciferians migrating to South Africa and taking over all the Administrative positions. Makow is a Jew—like Arthur Koestler—-but good info.

  36. Iceman,

    If leftists were serious about uplifting the working class, Obama wouldn’t have been overseas just the other day working on the massive Asia Pacific free trade agreement for the benefit of Wall Street.

  37. Quote: “Looking at the exit polls for California, Illinois, Michigan, Pennsylvania and even Maine, it is, with the exception of a small majority in Pennsylvania, white Catholic majorities that voted for Obama. Essentially, the descendants of southern and eastern Europeans and Irish Catholics still stand against the WASP founding American.”

    Yeah, because everyone knows that the Irish and the Italians love blacks. Seriously, as someone who comes from a white Catholic background I can tell you that there is little love for Obama and his race amongst my co-religionists and I can almost guarantee that in the northeastern part of the USA, Obama did better with white Protestants than he did with white Catholics. The only group more liberal than the Jews are the Yankee WASPs.

  38. Berz, good link. It made the Drudge Report today, too, so it’s going to get a lot of play.
    I’m going to post a link to it in the “Politics” section of the Forum and we can discuss there. It is certainly an article worthy of it’s own discussion.

    “Democratic operatives for the 2012 election make it clear for the first time that the party will explicitly abandon the white working class.”

    http://campaignstops.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/11/27/the-future-of-the-obama-coalition/

  39. RobRoySimmons says:
    November 28, 2011 at 2:17 am

    Actually Israel’s founders contained some like Moses Hess who believed in innate Ashkenazi genetic supremacism.

  40. Lindsay is largely right…the high school I attended in the late 1960s was undergoing great demographic change (whites moving out)…but at one point was about 60-40% white. Of the whites about 80% were what became called “yuppie” types, 20% second generation Appalacian working class.

    The 80% were mainly rock fans, but would listen to -and dig–Soul Music…Motown, then popular, and almost never to country. Folk had strayed over into folk-rock by then, but certain folkies were also injecting a little country twang, maybe a steel guitar, into their music. I had rocker friends who actually said things like ” I can listen occcasionally to folk or folk rock…but this (particular folk artist-group) has got too twangy, can’t take the twang,man.”

    This snobbery did not cross over however to actually befriending the negro students whose soul music it truly was…(or the “inferior” white Appalachians)…

  41. Lindsay is a liberal leftist.

    I am an authoritarian socialist who is conservative on social issues (such as abortion, race) but not conservative on religion.

    left-right spectrum does not speak in good enough detail.

  42. Keep your eyes on Waukesha, Wisconsin. Headquarters moving to China and 2 billion to help build our X Ray Equipment. This was news July 2011. Dont buy GE. 2 Billion approved by Obongo to train 65 engineers and what nots. I love White Country and Gospel and Blue Grass. But look what Johnny Cash did, he married a Mulatto. Also Willie Nelson went around years ago introducing Charlie Pride to White Crowds. Nelson according to late Pete Peters is half Jew. Most of Country now is NWO. Garth Brooks advocates, queers rights—-so much for modern Country. The list goes on and on. Ann Murray was popular and does not like being identified with country. She says she is POP. The Anti White Disease is everywhere. Buddy Tucker offers the best solution in his 10 Demandments! Your right Hunter these Northeast Establishment Liberals are behind most of this and this crap originated with them.

Comments are closed.