Paul Gottfried (Jew) weighs in on the Kaufmann vs. MacDonald debate and blames Anglo-Protestants for the self loathing version of multiculturalism. I can’t say that I agree with his interpretation.
Paul Gottfried said: “To put my cards on the table: I’ve never heard American Jews or American blacks pour as much contempt on white Protestant America as I hear coming from white Protestant intellectuals and clergy persons.”
–
Mr. Dithers said: “White self loathing didn’t happen spontaneously once upon a time. We do have some universalist tendencies in our DNA, but it was the Jews who constructed the anti-white ideologies that we languish under. Their gentile flunkies like Teddy Kennedy and others are just along for the ride.”
Completely on target –
[…] Corrupt church leaders are just trying to sell themselves to the public, as always. They conform to the attitudes of the public, whereas the media shape those attitudes. Church leaders, business leaders, entertainers, and everyone else operates in an atmosphere over which they have little control; they have to conform to political correctness; the jews of the media shape it. But you liars are content to speak about political correctness as though it were a force of nature, mysterious and unexplainable, unrelated to any real interests or tangible power. […]
Corrupt church leaders are just trying to sell themselves to the public, as always. They conform to the attitudes of the public, whereas the media shape those attitudes. Church leaders, business leaders, entertainers, and everyone else operates in an atmosphere over which they have little control; they have to conform to political correctness; the jews of the media shape it. [It is wrong] to speak about political correctness as though it were a force of nature, mysterious and unexplainable, unrelated to any real interests or tangible power.
That sounds completely right. And that was a good point about PC’s not being unexplainable like a force of nature but carefully imposed by specific, identifiable interest groups. I consider the (fill in the blank) ________ chief among the groups imposing it.
(The comment I quoted just above was Kulak’s.)
GR,
I must not have seen that comment.
Further to Mr. Dithers’ comment #50 and others like it questioning how Jewish observers like Prof. Gottfried could be so “unaware” of blindingly obvious Jewish culpability, here’s another example of the same mystifying phenomenon: a letter to the editor of Vdare.com posted yesterday went as follows:
“I just read [Professor] Weissberg’s column on the affirmative action Frankenstein. Going by [Prof.] Weissberg’s last name, I note that he conveniently forgot to mention that we would have no problems with minorities if it weren’t for organized Jewry. Weissberg knows the truth of this as well as anyone.”
Here is how Prof. Weissberg responded, with the same mystifying denial of major Jewish responsibility for what’s going on, and accusing the letter-writer of being motivated by “anti-Semitism”:
Robert Weissberg responds:
This is a deceptively important comment. Today’s forceful, unabashed patriotic conservatism (or whatever label one might use) cannot get out of first gear until it loses its anti-Semitic odor.
To be sure, Jews still flock to the Left though it is increasingly anti-Semitic. But old political habits die hard. So, just when Jews think it is safe to “go in there,” i.e., join the Right, something like this shows up. And I’m sure my Jewish friends will say, “See, I told you so, VDARE.COM is filled with Jew-haters, so why do you even associate with them?” If I had a nickel for every time I was asked why I write for VDARE.COM or Taki.mag since “they” are there, I would have at least a dollar.
What makes the anti-Semitism reflected in this letter so frustrating is that it is impervious to reason, let alone evidence. It is pointless to note that countless non-Jews vigorously pushed Affirmative Action (including Richard Nixon) or that many Jews abhor it. And that it’s equally foolish to needlessly antagonize potential Jewish allies with such rants.
Perchance an anti-Jewish is gene buried deeply in the conservative DNA and it just periodically erupts. This inclination is a disaster far beyond an ill-tempered comment.
I think that (unlike the majority of guys who comment at blogs such as this one and MajorityRights.com) I understand Jews almost perfectly. But I’m not able to understand how the Jews can fail to see that they, the Jews, both organized Jewry and influential Jews on an individual basis, have played and continue to play a very prominent role in all this (I consider theirs THE predominant role). I’m mystified by their blindness.
[…] Perchance an anti-Jewish is gene buried deeply in the conservative DNA and it just periodically erupts. This inclination is a disaster far beyond an ill-tempered comment. […]
What an unbelievably conceited comment! Only such a self-righteous jerk would say such a thing.
Obviously there is an ‘anti-gentile’ gene buried not-so-deeply in the ‘Khazar DNA’ that incessantly erupts. Like here.
Great quote, Fred!!
I never meant that we should exterminate Anglos or Jews. That would be immoral in the extreme. What I means is, through their own actions and policies, Anglos and Jews are ensuring their own destruction. The Anglos are submerging themselves in the tide of Third World immigration. And when we take into consideration all the damage that the Anglos and the Jews have inflicted on the Western world, why should we stop them? As a German whose grandparents lived in the Third Reich, why should I feel any sympathy for Anglos or Jews – the very races who destroyed my civilization?
Paul Gottfried said: “To put my cards on the table: I’ve never heard American Jews or American blacks pour as much contempt on white Protestant America as I hear coming from white Protestant intellectuals and clergy persons.”
–
Mr. Dithers said: “White self loathing didn’t happen spontaneously once upon a time. We do have some universalist tendencies in our DNA, but it was the Jews who constructed the anti-white ideologies that we languish under. Their gentile flunkies like Teddy Kennedy and others are just along for the ride.”
Completely on target –
[…] Corrupt church leaders are just trying to sell themselves to the public, as always. They conform to the attitudes of the public, whereas the media shape those attitudes. Church leaders, business leaders, entertainers, and everyone else operates in an atmosphere over which they have little control; they have to conform to political correctness; the jews of the media shape it. But you liars are content to speak about political correctness as though it were a force of nature, mysterious and unexplainable, unrelated to any real interests or tangible power. […]
http://www.heretical.com/miscella/fredtv.html
*Also see my posts #18 and #43.*
That sounds completely right. And that was a good point about PC’s not being unexplainable like a force of nature but carefully imposed by specific, identifiable interest groups. I consider the (fill in the blank) ________ chief among the groups imposing it.
(The comment I quoted just above was Kulak’s.)
GR,
I must not have seen that comment.
Further to Mr. Dithers’ comment #50 and others like it questioning how Jewish observers like Prof. Gottfried could be so “unaware” of blindingly obvious Jewish culpability, here’s another example of the same mystifying phenomenon: a letter to the editor of Vdare.com posted yesterday went as follows:
“I just read [Professor] Weissberg’s column on the affirmative action Frankenstein. Going by [Prof.] Weissberg’s last name, I note that he conveniently forgot to mention that we would have no problems with minorities if it weren’t for organized Jewry. Weissberg knows the truth of this as well as anyone.”
Here is how Prof. Weissberg responded, with the same mystifying denial of major Jewish responsibility for what’s going on, and accusing the letter-writer of being motivated by “anti-Semitism”:
I think that (unlike the majority of guys who comment at blogs such as this one and MajorityRights.com) I understand Jews almost perfectly. But I’m not able to understand how the Jews can fail to see that they, the Jews, both organized Jewry and influential Jews on an individual basis, have played and continue to play a very prominent role in all this (I consider theirs THE predominant role). I’m mystified by their blindness.
[…] Perchance an anti-Jewish is gene buried deeply in the conservative DNA and it just periodically erupts. This inclination is a disaster far beyond an ill-tempered comment. […]
What an unbelievably conceited comment! Only such a self-righteous jerk would say such a thing.
Obviously there is an ‘anti-gentile’ gene buried not-so-deeply in the ‘Khazar DNA’ that incessantly erupts. Like here.
Great quote, Fred!!
I never meant that we should exterminate Anglos or Jews. That would be immoral in the extreme. What I means is, through their own actions and policies, Anglos and Jews are ensuring their own destruction. The Anglos are submerging themselves in the tide of Third World immigration. And when we take into consideration all the damage that the Anglos and the Jews have inflicted on the Western world, why should we stop them? As a German whose grandparents lived in the Third Reich, why should I feel any sympathy for Anglos or Jews – the very races who destroyed my civilization?